EU to reveal winners of first green hydrogen subsidy auction at end of April

Senior European Commission official urges member states to use Hydrogen Bank scheme for 'auctions as a service' to avoid the UK's mistake of overpaying for H2

Johanna Schiele, policy officer for the Innovation Fund at the European Commission speaking earlier today at the Reuters Hydrogen 2024 conference in Amsterdam.
Johanna Schiele, policy officer for the Innovation Fund at the European Commission speaking earlier today at the Reuters Hydrogen 2024 conference in Amsterdam.Photo: Reuters Events

The European Commission will publish the results of its €800m ($869m) pilot auction for hydrogen subsidies on 30 April, policy officer Johanna Schiele announced today.

Stay ahead on hydrogen with our free newsletter

Keep up with the latest developments in the international hydrogen industry with the free Accelerate Hydrogen newsletter. Sign up now for an unbiased, clear-sighted view of the fast-growing hydrogen sector.
Sign up now
Only last week, EU energy commissioner Kadri Simson told a gathering in Australia that the winners would be revealed in May.
While Schiele — described as one of the architects of the European Hydrogen Bank support scheme for H2 — was reluctant to provide too many details before winners were unveiled, she declared onstage at the Reuters Hydrogen 2024 conference that the Commission is “very happy with the price level we saw in the auction”.

This would suggest that EU would continue to offer fixed-payment subsidies of up to €4.50/kg at the next auction, which is due to take place near the end of this year.

The European Commission will “tweak the edges” of the second auction based on the results of the first as well as industry feedback, Schiele said, although a switch to a Contracts for Difference model is unlikely until a market develops.

Given that the 132 bidders had to provide information on where they planned to source electrolysers for their projects, Schiele hinted that there would be “lively debate” on whether the second auction should specifically support projects using equipment made in Europe.

She added that while the Net Zero Industry Act — a proposed EU measure that would incentivise the European manufacturing sector to supply 40% of clean-tech equipment deployed within the bloc — would not necessarily apply to the European Hydrogen Bank, “we will fall in line with the Commission’s policy trend”.

Auctions as a service

The European Commission is pushing for more member states to use the EHB for its “auctions as a service” model, in which countries can channel state aid through the process towards projects within their borders.

“We don’t want 27 member states to come out with 27 different hydrogen support schemes,” said Schiele, noting that Germany and Austria are injecting €350m and €400m, respectively, towards the pilot auction.

She pointed out that auction design can also massively influence how much governments end up paying green hydrogen producers, citing the example of the UK, which is set to spend £2bn ($2.54bn) on 125MW of electrolyser projects.

The strike price of £241/MWh at higher heating value corresponds to around £9.49 ($12.06) per kilogram of H2 — more than double the EU’s cap.

Schiele noted that part of the reason for this is that prices rose during the long period of negotiation between the UK government and hydrogen project developers.

“The UK is also paying the difference between the natural gas price and the hydrogen price in a Contract for Difference,” she added, noting that this removed the incentive for H2 producers to find offtakers willing to pay the lowest possible price.
(Copyright)
Published 10 April 2024, 12:30Updated 10 April 2024, 12:30